Explore through two lenses
SR/EN
AUTHORITARIANISM - RESEARCH ATLASAVtokratija

How the authoritarian system works in Serbia

General research connected to documented examples, findings, and sources from Serbia.

100questions
20areas
148academic works
130Serbia sources
Go to the general AUTLAS Explore general mechanisms of authoritarian systems without the Serbia evidence layer.
→

SIX ENTRIES INTO THE MATRIX

Which question do you want to start with?

Concrete questions are the starting point. The other 94 are available through the map of 20 areas.

MAP OF THE AUTHORITARIAN SYSTEM

Twenty areas guide you through the system as a whole.

Select an area to see why it matters and which five questions it opens.

AVTOKRATIJA›Why the police, military, and security services obey
16
Research-based answerAUTLAS Research Base

Why do the police, military, and security services agree to carry out politically risky orders?

Confidence in the conclusionquite substantiated, with important conditions
key academic works5
linked Serbia sources11
Period2012-2026; particularly the 2020 and 2025 protests

Police officers, soldiers and service members do not follow risky political orders just because they are “obedient”. They assess who is likely to remain in power, who controls their salary and promotion, what will happen to their family and whether they will one day be held accountable for what they have done.

The authorities increase obedience by choosing loyal elders, special privileges, supervision within the services and the message that the refusal will be punished quickly, while the execution will remain unpunished. It is also important what their colleagues do: the individual is much more difficult to refuse the order if he thinks that he will remain alone. That is why the behavior of the services in crisis can change abruptly when they assess that the balance of forces is changing and that the old protection is no longer safe.

Example from SerbiaChecked 11 sources; 9 manufacturers
11 related sources; 9 groups of evidence producers; domestic NGOs/research producers: 3

A policeman or a member of the service in Serbia does not only decide whether he agrees with the political leadership. The assessment is shaped by the chain of command, the possibility of advancement or punishment, legal protection, the expectation that the order will be investigated and the belief that the current government will survive. When supervision and responsibility are weak, the personal risk of rejection may be higher than the risk of executing the disputed order.

How the finding is separated in the matrix

01 Established fact

BCSP documents the politicization and weak control of the sector, while domestic and international organizations recorded allegations of excessive force and slow or ineffective liability during the protest.

02 Our interpretation

Obedience does not have to mean ideological loyalty. Often a rational response to a hierarchy in which the immediate punishment for disobedience is certain, and the future punishment for abuse is uncertain.

03 Does it show the same process?

Yes sources well underpin the structure of incentives, but the motive of each individual officer remains different.

04 Important caveat or alternative explanation

The allegation of illegal force requires an independent investigation in case. The entire police force must not be declared a political perpetrator on the basis of the actions of individual units or commanders.

What the general answer does not allow us to conclude

We often find out about the internal decisions of the police and the military only after the crisis. One case can well explain the procedure, but it does not have to be valid everywhere.

Works supporting this answer, with their evidence type and an explanation of how they relate to the claim.

A01

comparing several countries or cases

Greitens, S. C. (2016), Dictators and Their Secret Police: Coercive Institutions and State Violence, Cambridge University Press.

Contribution to this answer
Greitens shows how the organization of the security apparatus shapes to whom the forced services are loyal and what kind of repression they can carry out. Individual obedience depends on the institution in which the official works, not only on the personal attitude.
Open source ↗
A02

comparing several countries or cases

Talmadge, C. (2015), The Dictator’s Army, Cornell University Press.

Contribution to this answer
Talmadge shows that political criteria in promotion, command and training can increase loyalty to the regime, but at the same time weaken professional military capability. Career structure therefore changes the calculation of officers.
Open source ↗
A03

comparing several countries or cases

Barany, Z. (2016), How Armies Respond to Revolutions and Why, Princeton University Press.

Contribution to this answer
Barany shows why the army in some revolutions defends the regime, in others it refuses to shoot, and in the third it is divided. The decision depends on the cohesion of the army, relations with the government, legitimacy, the character of the protest and the external environment.
Open source ↗
A04

data from a large number of countries

Paine, J. (2022), „Reframing the Guardianship Dilemma: How the Military’s Dual Disloyalty Options Imperil Dictators“, American Political Science Review 116(4): 1425–1442.

Contribution to this answer
Paine shows that the military has two types of possible disobedience it can threaten the dictator with a coup or refuse to protect him from opponents. The way the leader organizes civil-military relations tries to reduce both risks.
Open source ↗
A05

comparing several countries or cases

Svolik, M. W. (2012), The Politics of Authoritarian Rule, Cambridge University Press.

Contribution to this answer
Svolik provides a broader framework: the apparatus of force is part of a coalition that maintains authoritarian power, but its members have their own interests and can become a threat to the leader. That is why the regime must constantly manage their loyalty.
Open source ↗

Sources supporting the Serbia example, with the claim they support and their limitations.

S01

Domestic NGOs research report - Verified 21.08.2026

Đokić, Katarina, Saša Đorđević, Marija Ignjatijević, Jelena Pejić Nikić i Predrag Petrović. 2020. Security Sector Capture in Serbia – An Early Study. Beograd: Beogradski centar za bezbednosnu politiku.

What the source records
The study links a greater number of cases of both primary and secondary sources to show patterns of political control, weakening surveillance and use of security institutions in the interest of the ruling structure.
Claim it supports
Document political ties, hierarchy and weak accountability that shape the incentives of officials.
Source limitation
Authors expressly present it as an early and sectoral study; it does not measure each institution or prove that each individual procedure is centrally ordered.
Open source ↗
S02

Domestic NGOs annual monitoring of human rights - Verified 21.08.2026

Beogradski centar za ljudska prava. 2026. Human Rights in Serbia 2025. Urednik Dušan Pokuševski. Beograd: Beogradski centar za ljudska prava.

What the source records
The twenty-eighth annual report documents systemic pressures and violations of rights in 2025 and brings together data from institutions and sectoral organisations on the prosecution of protest participants and incidents towards journalists.
Claim it supports
Annual monitoring of human rights records police conduct and the issue of responsibility in a protest context.
Source limitation
The report follows the rights and institutional treatment, not the type of regime; part of the numerical data is taken from state authorities and other organizations and should be read with their original records.
Open source ↗
S03

Domestic NGO monitoring of civic space - Verified 21.08.2026

Građanske inicijative. 2025. Udruženja građana — sužavanje prostora za delovanje 2024. Beograd: Građanske inicijative.

What the source records
Based on the standardized regional matrix and bi-weekly reports, 234 cases of violations of fundamental rights and freedoms were registered, with an increase in physical and verbal attacks and other pressures compared to the previous year.
Claim it supports
Domestic monitoring of the civic space collects cases of arrest, violence and intimidation of activists.
Source limitation
The records include documented and reported cases, and not a representative rate of all incidents in Serbia, while the organization at the same time has a clear role of protecting the civil space.
Open source ↗
S04

Official international monitoring - Verified 21.08.2026

European Commission. 2025. Serbia 2025 Report. Commission Staff Working Document. Brussels: European Commission.

What the source records
The report notes weak election conditions, limited parliamentary scrutiny, strong political pressure on the judiciary and concerns that the president is in practice directing decision-making beyond the constitutional idea.
Claim it supports
The EU report provides an independent external review of problems with police accountability and fundamental rights.
Source limitation
The report is related to the EU accession process and describes a certain period; it does not represent a scientific causal study or a uniform assessment of the type of regime.
Open source ↗
S05

Reviewed scientific work - Verified 21.08.2026

Petrović, Valentina. 2025. “Under Pressure: The Politics of Clientelism and Coercion in Serbia.” Democratization, online first: 1–26. https://doi.org/10.1080/13510347.2025.2520349

What the source records
The survey shows that political coercion relies on economic and institutional dependence, not just ideological consent.
Claim it supports
Supports the interpretation that the perpetrator assesses the career, safety and price of disobedience, not just the content of the order.
Source limitation
Measures of experience and observation in one year; cannot verify each reported practice as a single legal case.
Open source ↗
S06

Domestic think tank analysis of a protest cycle - Viewed full report, summary and description of events

Đorđević, Saša. 2020. Spontani protest i postupanje policije. Beograd: Beogradski centar za bezbednosnu politiku.

What the source records
“In July 2020, it records the violence of acts of protesters, but also brutal or excessive police force, attacks on journalists and issues of command responsibility.
Claim it supports
It shows how the chain of command and institutional reaction shape the implementation of a risky order on the ground.
Source limitation
A brief analysis of one protest relies in part on media and open sources; not all interventions are listed and the responsibility of individual police officers is established.
Open source ↗
S07

Domestic Center for Human Rights Analysis of Cases and Evidence - Viewed full report, documented chronology and listed items

Ilić, Vladica, Sanja Radivojević i Luka Mihajlović. 2021. Istrage slučajeva policijskog zlostavljanja na julskim građanskim protestima 2020. godine. Beograd: Beogradski centar za ljudska prava.

What the source records
Monitors how reports, recordings and medical documentation passed through the prosecutor’s office and internal control, with delays and difficulties of identification.
Claim it supports
substantiates that the expectation of weak individual responsibility reduces the future risk of executing the disputed order.
Source limitation
The authors represent a part of the damaged and analyze a protest cycle; the submitted reports are not the same as the convictions, and the findings about the omissions do not prove every reported action.
Open source ↗
S08

Official international contractual monitoring of human rights - Viewed full adopted document, especially points 2627 and 4043

United Nations Human Rights Committee. 2024. Concluding Observations on the Fourth Periodic Report of Serbia. CCPR/C/SRB/CO/4, 3 May 2024.

What the source records
The UN committee finds a high number of complaints, low prosecution rates, and an absence of accountability for police officers in the 2020 protests.
Claim it supports
Independently confirms the mechanism in which the penalty for overdraft is uncertain, while the hierarchical command is immediate.
Source limitation
The Contracting Authority assesses the state data and alternative reports at the system level; it is not an immediate investigation commission for each incident, nor does it turn every claim into a judicially established fact.
Open source ↗
S09

International Organization for Human Rights annual monitoring - Official Earth Report 2025/26

Amnesty International. 2026. The State of the World’s Human Rights 2025/26 — Serbia.

What the source records
For 2025, there is excessive force, intimidation and beatings during mostly peaceful protests throughout Serbia.
Claim it supports
He adds contemporary evidence that the politically risky use of force does not come down to a single event in 2020.
Source limitation
Annual monitoring summarizes documented cases and partner findings, but is not a list of each intervention or a final decision on individual responsibility; the same manufacturer also has a forensic report on the control in the matrix.
Open source ↗
S10

International Field Inspection Council of Europe - Full official report, method, findings and response from the Government

European Committee for the Prevention of Torture and Inhuman or Degrading Treatment or Punishment (CPT). 2024. Report to the Serbian Government on the Visit to Serbia from 21 to 30 March 2023. CPT/Inf (2024) 04.

What the source records
The field delegation, through interviews, files and medical documentation, finds severe abuses and weaknesses of investigations, with the testimony of many about the correct treatment.
Claim it supports
It shows how the real probability of investigation and sanctions shape professional incentives in the police chain.
Source limitation
The targeted visit to selected institutions does not measure the national abuse rate and primarily refers to suspects and detainees, not just political protests.
Open source ↗
S11

Primary source finding of an independent state body - Full official report and section on police conduct

Zaštitnik građana Republike Srbije. 2022. Redovan godišnji izveštaj Zaštitnika građana za 2021. godinu.

What the source records
The Protector establishes illegal conduct and violation of rights in one case from the protest, as well as omissions of documentation and identification.
Claim it supports
Primary domestic findings show that responsibility depends on whether the use of force is recorded and the officer can be identified.
Source limitation
The primary finding includes the subject matter in the Ombudsman’s jurisdiction and does not mean that all the allegations have been confirmed; part of the recommendations are aimed at future practice and not at sanction in any previous case.
Open source ↗

ABOUT US AND OUR METHODOLOGY

Many sources. Clear methodology. Verifiable answers.

AUTLAS is a public knowledge platform about how authoritarian systems work. It turns research into clear answers about elections, media, institutions, public resources, pressure, and everyday life.

01

Based on academic research

Answers draw on academic research on authoritarian systems, democratic backsliding, institutional capture, and the narrowing of civic rights and freedoms.

02

Practice documented in Serbia

AVtokratija is the Serbia case study within AUTLAS. It uses reports, analyses, and data from relevant organizations, institutions, and investigative media. General findings and Serbia evidence are presented separately.

03

Sources open to scrutiny

Each answer lists its sources so visitors can check the basis for its conclusions.

04

Why questions?

AUTLAS organizes dispersed knowledge through 100 questions in 20 areas, helping people understand the wider system behind familiar phenomena.

05

Focus on the system

AUTLAS analyzes rules, incentives, pressures, and institutional mechanisms.

06

Who is behind AUTLAS?

AUTLAS and AVtokratija were conceived and are developed by Civic Initiatives. Content is updated in line with new research and reliable data.

CONTINUOUSLY UPDATED

Help us keep the content complete and accurate.

Send a relevant source, point out an error, or suggest how an explanation could be clearer. Every submission is reviewed before the content is changed.

Send a source, report an error, or share a suggestion