Do all authoritarian governments operate in the same way?
Not all authoritarian authorities function the same, even when they similarly limit political competition and control of power. Somewhere the leader relies on a strong ruling party, somewhere on the army, the royal family, security services or a narrow personal circle, and somewhere there is an opposition that participates in elections under extremely unequal conditions.
It depends on who can stop the leader, how the positions and money are shared, how much open force is used and what happens when the leader leaves. That is why the same event protest, election defeat or economic crisis in different systems can produce completely different consequences. The markings help to ask the right questions, but they can not replace the description of the real power relations in a particular country.
Election monitoring shows that in Serbia the opposition participates in the elections and that political competition formally exists, but also that the conditions are not equal. The government has much greater media visibility, benefits from the benefits of the public function and state resources, while a part of voters and employees are exposed to pressures. This shows that authoritarian control does not have to abolish the elections: it is enough to permanently facilitate one side and make it harder for the other to win voters and take power.
How the finding is separated in the matrix
Domestic sources show that in Serbia there are elections, opposition, parliament, critical media, protests and organizations, but that inequality is produced differently: through public resources and pressures in elections, pronounced media dominance, weakening parliamentary oversight, political ties in the security sector and increasing the price of civic organizing.
This is different from a closed one-party or military dictatorship. Control is often achieved by selective application of existing rules and institutions, and not by their complete abolition, with different sectors using different mechanisms.
Yes domestic sources show multiple mechanisms within a competitive authoritarian form
The sector report speaks only about the area it follows, and documented incidents are not representative of each institution or citizen. The conclusion on the type of system therefore arises only when the sectoral findings intersect with scientific and comparative research.
Systems change and mix properties of multiple species. The label helps to compare, but never explains the whole country.
Works supporting this answer, with their evidence type and an explanation of how they relate to the claim.
review more research
Geddes, B., Wright, J. i Frantz, E. (2018), How Dictatorships Work, Cambridge University Press.
- Contribution to this answer
- Geddes, Wright and Frantz show that dictatorships differ in who founded them, how the government is organized, how power is shared and how the regime is personalized. These differences strongly affect their behavior and duration.
comparison of different types of systems
Wahman, M., Teorell, J. i Hadenius, A. (2013), „Authoritarian Regime Types Revisited: Updated Data in Comparative Perspective“, Contemporary Politics 19(1): 19–34.
Wahman, M., Teorell, J. i Hadenius, A. (2013), "Authoritarian Regime Types Revisited: Updated Data in Comparative Perspective", Contemporary Politics 19(1): 19–34.
- Contribution to this answer
- Wahman, Teorell, and Hadenius show that within the authoritarian world there are different electoral, party, military, and monarchical patterns, so the unification of all autocracy into one category hides important differences.
Development and verification of measurement methods
Teorell, J. i Lindberg, S. I. (2019), „Beyond Democracy–Dictatorship Measures: A New Framework Capturing Executive Bases of Power, 1789–2016“, Perspectives on Politics 17(1): 66–84.
- Contribution to this answer
- Teorell and Lindbergh show that the basics of executive power can be different and overlap. The two regimes that act similarly on the outside can therefore rest on quite different mechanisms of coming to power and its loss.
review more research
Brancati, D. (2014), „Democratic Authoritarianism: Origins and Effects“, Annual Review of Political Science 17: 313–326.
- Contribution to this answer
- Brancati shows that the same formal institutions elections, parties, assemblies can perform different tasks in different autocracy: from information gathering to the distribution of benefits and control of political actors.
comparing several countries or cases
Svolik, M. W. (2012), The Politics of Authoritarian Rule, Cambridge University Press.
- Contribution to this answer
- Svolik shows that authoritarian systems solve two separate problems control of society and power sharing among the elites and that different institutions can be made to solve different parts of the problem.
Sources supporting the Serbia example, with the claim they support and their limitations.
Reviewed scientific work - Verified 21.08.2026
Bieber, Florian. 2018. “Patterns of Competitive Authoritarianism in the Western Balkans.” East European Politics 34(3): 337–354. https://doi.org/10.1080/21599165.2018.1490272
- What the source records
- Comparison of old and new patterns of competitive authoritarianism in the Western Balkans, including Serbia.
- Claim it supports
- Bieber explicitly distinguishes contemporary competitive authoritarian regimes of the Western Balkans from regimes of the 1990s and shows that different types use different supports and tactics.
- Source limitation
- The regional comparison does not provide equally detailed evidence for every institution in Serbia.
Reviewed scientific work - Verified 21.08.2026
Castaldo, Antonino. 2020. “Back to Competitive Authoritarianism? Democratic Backsliding in Vučić’s Serbia.” Europe-Asia Studies 72(10): 1617–1638. https://doi.org/10.1080/09668136.2020.1817860
- What the source records
- Changing the type of regime in Serbia using V-Dem indicators and dozens of criteria of competitive authoritarianism.
- Claim it supports
- Castaldo describes Serbia as a competitive authoritarianism, i.e. a system with real political competition that is seriously distorted, and not as a completely closed autocracy.
- Source limitation
- The classification depends on the thresholds chosen and the data for the most part precedes the 2020-2025 elections.
Reviewed scientific work - Verified 21.08.2026
Laštro, Claudia, i Florian Bieber. 2021. “The Performance of Opposition Parties in Competitive Authoritarian Regimes: Three Case Studies from the Western Balkans.” European Political Science 20(4): 617–629. https://doi.org/10.1057/s41304-021-00326-w
- What the source records
- How opposition parties operate in competitively authoritarian regimes of Serbia, Montenegro and North Macedonia.
- Claim it supports
- A comparison of the opposition in three countries shows that within the same broad type of regime, there are different chances for unification, electoral breakthrough and the change of power.
- Source limitation
- The emphasis is on opposition strategies and regional comparison, not on all parts of the state apparatus.
International scientific base and report - Verified 21.08.2026
Nord, Marina, David Altman, Tiago Fernandes, Ana Good God, i Staffan I. Lindberg. 2026. Democracy Report 2026: Unraveling the Democratic Era? University of Gothenburg: V-Dem Institute, dataset v16.
- What the source records
- Hundreds of indicators of elections, freedoms, the rule of law and the limitations of executive power over time.
- Claim it supports
- V-Dem distinguishes electoral from closed autocracy and puts Serbia in the first group, thus clearly showing that the existence of multi-party elections changes the way the system works.
- Source limitation
- Categories depend on thresholds and expert assessments; the report itself warns of measurable uncertainty, and RoW typology is not the official position of V-Dem project management bodies.
International expert report - Verified 21.08.2026
Bertelsmann Stiftung. 2026. BTI 2026 Serbia Country Report. Gütersloh: Bertelsmann Stiftung.
- What the source records
- Elections, rule of law, institutions, governance, economy and political integration in Serbia.
- Claim it supports
- BTI calls Serbia a moderate autocracy and describes in detail the institutions through which power is exercised, which makes it possible to compare the label with the actual mechanisms.
- Source limitation
- It is a periodic expert assessment with its own methodology, not a peer-reviewed work that isolates a single cause.
Independent annual monitoring - Verified 21.08.2026
Burazer, Nikola. 2024. Serbia: Nations in Transit 2024 Country Report. Washington, DC: Freedom House.
- What the source records
- Seven areas of democracy, including elections, media, local government, judiciary, corruption and civil society.
- Claim it supports
- Nations in Transit calls Serbia a hybrid regime, so it shows that serious sources can name the same border space between democracy and autocracy differently.
- Source limitation
- The assessments are expert and based on the thresholds of the organization; individual claims should be verified by primary and additional sources.
Independent annual monitoring - Verified 21.08.2026
Freedom House. 2026. Freedom in the World 2026: Serbia Country Report. Washington, DC: Freedom House.
- What the source records
- Political rights and civil liberties, including elections, pluralism, expression, association and the rule of law.
- Claim it supports
- Freedom in the World retains the rating of a partially free country with multi-party elections, but it notes serious limitations, which further confirms that authoritarian systems are not equally closed.
- Source limitation
- A broad assessment of rights and freedoms does not explain the causes themselves, and the methodology and thresholds are not the same as with V-Dem, BTI or academic typologies.
Domestic NGOs election monitoring - Verified 21.08.2026
CRTA. 2024. Final Election Observation Report – 2023. Beograd: CRTA Election Observation Mission.
- What the source records
- Displays the system with elections, opposition and formal procedures, but with deeply unequal conditions.
- Claim it supports
- CRTA’s monitoring shows one particular authoritarian form: elections and alternatives exist, but their equality is undermined through institutions, resources and pressures.
- Source limitation
- The finding refers to one election cycle and represents an expert assessment of the domestic observation mission, not a court ruling or independent classification of the entire regime.
Domestic NGOs systematic media monitoring - Verified 21.08.2026
CRTA. 2025. Media Monitoring of Political Pluralism: Government in Focus, Opposition Almost Invisible. Beograd: CRTA.
- What the source records
- Shows indirect control of political visibility through strong dominance and tone on television, not through a formal ban on opposition.
- Claim it supports
- This source shows that authoritarian control can be carried out through unequal access and favorable reporting, without closing all critical media.
- Source limitation
- The sample includes the central news of five national TV stations, but does not measure all media, the entire program offer, the audience or the direct impact of such reporting on voting.
Domestic NGOs parliamentary monitoring - Verified 21.08.2026
Otvoreni parlament. 2025. Godišnji izveštaj o radu XIV saziva Narodne skupštine, februar 2024 – april 2025. Beograd: CRTA.
- What the source records
- “It shows that parliament has not been abolished, but that its controlling role can be emptied through procedures, mostly through biased leadership.
- Claim it supports
- “This report helps us understand the hybrid form of government in which a democratic institution remains visible, but is increasingly failing to perform its function.
- Source limitation
- It includes one convocation and one institution, so it cannot explain the entire system itself or determine the motives of every MP and official.
Domestic NGOs research report - Verified 21.08.2026
Đokić, Katarina, Saša Đorđević, Marija Ignjatijević, Jelena Pejić Nikić i Predrag Petrović. 2020. Security Sector Capture in Serbia – An Early Study. Beograd: Beogradski centar za bezbednosnu politiku.
- What the source records
- Document special mechanisms for the capture of police, services and defence that differ from electoral and media mechanisms.
- Claim it supports
- The study shows that within the same country authoritarian control does not work the same everywhere: in the security sector, it uses different connections, secrecy and surveillance than in elections or in the media.
- Source limitation
- Authors expressly present it as an early and sectoral study; it does not measure each institution or prove that each individual procedure is centrally ordered.
Domestic NGOs annual monitoring of human rights - Verified 21.08.2026
Beogradski centar za ljudska prava. 2026. Human Rights in Serbia 2025. Urednik Dušan Pokuševski. Beograd: Beogradski centar za ljudska prava.
- What the source records
- A combination of legal restrictions, police action, prosecution and pressure is recorded, while there is a mass civil mobilization.
- Claim it supports
- “This report shows that authoritarian rule does not have to completely stifle society: protest and resistance can remain strong while the state increases the cost of using them.
- Source limitation
- The report follows the rights and institutional treatment, not the type of regime; part of the numerical data is taken from state authorities and other organizations and should be read with their original records.
Domestic NGO monitoring of civic space - Verified 21.08.2026
Građanske inicijative. 2025. Udruženja građana — sužavanje prostora za delovanje 2024. Beograd: Građanske inicijative.
- What the source records
- Displays various forms of pressure on association, expression and gathering through concrete cases throughout Serbia.
- Claim it supports
- This monitoring shows a variety of mechanisms from administrative barriers and smear campaigns to physical attacks instead of a single formula of authoritarian control.
- Source limitation
- The records include documented and reported cases, and not a representative rate of all incidents in Serbia, while the organization at the same time has a clear role of protecting the civil space.
Domestic NGOs and research media case study - Verified 21.08.2026
Cvijić, Srđan. 2018. When Law Doesn’t Rule: State Capture of the Judiciary, Prosecution, Police in Serbia. Open Society European Policy Institute, Transparentnost Srbija i CINS.
- What the source records
- Describes political control through administrative and legal weaknesses, discretion and selective treatment, rather than through the abolition of justice and police.
- Claim it supports
- This study shows how contemporary authoritarian authorities can use existing rules and institutions selectively, instead of openly abolishing them.
- Source limitation
- Cases precede recent institutional changes and cannot prove that every action today is politically controlled, but they provide an important early point for monitoring continuity.
The International Longitudinal Democratic Index - Viewed official website, methodological framework and Serbia profile
International IDEA. 2025. Serbia — The Global State of Democracy (GSoD) Democracy Tracker. Poslednje ažuriranje: septembar 2025.
- What the source records
- Serbia remains in the middle range by main categories, but with significant declines in the credibility of elections, parliament and freedoms.
- Claim it supports
- Supports nuanced classification: formal pluralism and elections can survive while certain democratic dimensions weaken.
- Source limitation
- Composite indicators and expert assessments show the direction and dimensions of the change, but do not isolate one cause or prove each individual event.
Independent international monitoring of media pluralism - Viewed official country page and available full report
Centre for Media Pluralism and Media Freedom (CMPF), European University Institute. 2026. Media Pluralism Monitor 2026: Serbia.
- What the source records
- Breaks down the media system into four types of risks, with political independence being the most vulnerable, but problems vary by market, protection and inclusion.
- Claim it supports
- “It shows that within no hybrid system, all areas do not function the same and that the type of regime cannot be reduced to one feature.
- Source limitation
- It is a structured expert risk assessment that also uses local sources; it does not measure hypothetical election results without media bias or each newsroom individually.
Domestic media associations survey and qualitative research - Verified 21.08.2026
Asocijacija medija, AOM, NDNV, NUNS, Lokal pres i Slavko Ćuruvija fondacija. 2023. Strategija razvoja medijskog sistema Srbije (2020–2025) i njena implementacija: saznanja, stavovi i predlozi medijskih radnika. Beograd.
- What the source records
- Record various mechanisms of political influence through financing, regulators and the application of media rules.
- Claim it supports
- Complements typology with domestic proof that control can be carried out indirectly, through market and regulatory levers, and not just through prohibition.
- Source limitation
- The sample of media workers and interviews do not represent all the newsrooms or the entire audience; they find measures of experience and attitudes of the professional community.
Domestic NGOs representative public opinion - Verified 21.08.2026
CRTA i Democracy Action Lab. 2026. Veruju u demokratiju, ne veruju u vlast: istraživanje javnog mnjenja u Srbiji. Beograd: CRTA.
- What the source records
- At the same time, public opinion shows support for democracy and low confidence in its functioning and the main institutions.
- Claim it supports
- It shows that support for a democratic ideal can exist in a system with weakened controls, which is typical of mixed and hybrid forms.
- Source limitation
- The survey measures attitudes at a time of great political mobilization and cannot explain on its own why people support different, sometimes contradictory values at the same time.
Local media network local survey and field research - Full report and methodology reviewed
Cvejić, Bojan, i ANEM. 2026. Indikatori stanja lokalnih medija u Srbiji za 2025. godinu: studija slučaja osam gradova i opština i jednog regiona.
- What the source records
- Finds major differences among local communities in freedom, security, economic position and access to information.
- Claim it supports
- Local variation confirms that the same country does not function equally in all environments and sectors.
- Source limitation
- The sample of journalists and selected environments are not representative of the whole of Serbia, and the evaluations express the experiences and assessments of the participants, not the rate of all incidents.
Is a relevant source missing? Send it to us.
Suggest a source or report an error in this answer →